Life after Dead Space 3

EDIT: Thanks for your feedback, r/patientgamers. I analyzed your recommendations below and worked them into the list. I now started to play Darksiders II and tried Alan Wake: AN and FC3: BloodDragon as some of you advised I'd be easier to first play something short. Your recommendations were profound and I will consider them when playing through the back log! Yet I wonder how games like NiNoKuni could get such little love and MGS4 not even one. Didn't they stood the test of time? I'll put my feedback into the subreddit once I'm finished with them. ;)

Finished Dead Space 3 today (found it to be good overall, just not as great as 1 and 2) and wondering which game of my backlog to play next. Help me out, your suggestions are very welcome! Keep in mind that I'm mostly a single player. Thanks in advance. The backlog:

Resident Evil Revelations (360)

Gears of War Judgment (360 - already played a few chapters, seems okay, weird narration, not a must play like previous GOWs) (1 recommendation)

Dirt 2 (360 - loved the first one back in the day, Dirt 2 seems to be decent) (1 recommendation)

Fallout: New Vegas (360 - in 20 hours, gave up then as it just didn't click for me like Fallout 3 did) (2 recommendations)

Dishonored (360 - played the first half hour, very promising) (4 recommendations)

Ridge Racer Unbounded (360 - seems pretty bad)

Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter 2 (360 - first one was cool, this one a little outdated nowadays maybe?)

Tomb Raider Collection (360) (1 recommendation)

Resident Evil 6 (360 - played a little, how can RE have become this bad??)

Darksiders II (360 - absolutely loved the first one and looking forward to this since a long time) (1 recommendation)

LA Noire (360 - played a little, slow pace, not like GTA) (3 recommendations)

Dark Souls ( 360 - played a little, very hard, ugly characters, unique atmosphere, not insta-addicting) (5 recommendations)

GTA IV: Ballad of Gay Tony (360 - in the middle, didn't like it as much as The Lost and The Damned) (1 recommendation)

Borderlands 2 (360 - still need to go through some of the Add Ons)

Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Future Soldier (360 - played a few hours campaign with a friend, fun Tom Clancy game)

X-Com Enemy Unknown (360 - stuck in the first alien base, great game)

Assassin's Creed III + Add Ons (360 - loved the ACs with Ezio) (2 recommendations)

Skyrim Legendary (360 - love this game, finished the main story line and still need to go for the add ons)

Diablo 3 (360 - played a little, not as great as Diablo II back in the day) (1 recommendation)

Alan Wake: American Nightmare (360 - liked the original game a lot)

Far Cry 3: Blood Dragon (360) (4 recommendations)

Need for Speed Most Wanted 2 (360 - the first from 2006 is still my favorite racing game, curious if this one can catch up)

Injustice Gods Among Us (PS3)

Killzone 2 (PS3 - was hyped back in the day, curious) (1 recommendation)

The Last of Us (PS3 - legendary reputation) (2 recommendations)

NiNoKuni (PS3 - played the first three hours, only good JRPG last gen, very nice game) (1 recommendation)

Uncharted 3 (PS3 - played 1 and 2, very entertaining, Drake is cool) (1 recommendation)

God of War Ascension (PS3 - watched a few minutes when my sister played, the focus seems to be on gore, not gameplay)

Metal Gear Solid 4 (PS3 - loved MGS1 and 3)